Category Archives: Alternate Energy

Solar Hot Water part IV

Update: The larger pump did the trick. Yesterday (a nice sunny day) the temperature in the bottom of the solar tank was 120 degrees when I got home. This is about where I thought it should be all along. I will start to calculate my electric savings now. In a few months I should have a good idea of the savings.

Original post:

Because good enough is never good enough, I have been tinkering with the solar hot water system. I want every BTU I can get these days, so it is all about efficiency. About a week ago, I noticed that my heat exchanger was not working very well.

The heat exchanger takes the hot water from the solar panels on the roof and runs the cold water from the bottom of the solar tank through and heats it up. One measure of how the heat exchanger is working is the difference in temperature input vs. output. There should be a drop of several degrees as the heat is removed and put into storage. In my system, it was only about 1 to 2 degrees.

I also noticed that the solar hot water storage tank never fully heated up. A few quick calculations in my head showed that it should have, on at lease a few sunny days, reached 100-110 degrees. Therefore I began investigating.

The first thing I looked at was the flow rates of the two pumps. See diagram below. The first pump pushes the water up to the panels and back, it is a TACO 009B. It has to overcome a static head (head is the pressure of the weight of the water and is a function of gravity defined by P=rho g h, where rho is the density, g is the acceleration due to gravity and h is the height) of 22 feet, plus a friction head of 3 feet (friction head is the resistance of the pipe itself and is a function of pipe size, bends and flow rate). This is well within the pumps capacity and the flow meter installed shows a rate of ~6 gallons per minute, which is actually a bit high for the collectors.

The second pump is a TACO 003B which circulates the water from the storage tank through the heat exchanger and back. It has no static head, as the entire loop is pressurized potable water. It does have about considerable friction head due to the finned heat exchanger. My theory was that this pump was not circulating enough cold water through the heat exchanger to remove all the heat coming from the collectors on the roof.

Click on picture for hi-res file.

solar hot water system

A look at the 003B pump curve shows it has a shut off head of 5 feet, which when looking at the installation, it must be close to.

I decided to change the smaller pump to the next available size, a TACO 006B. I removed the old pump and soldered in the new one. Unfortunately, it was cloudy for a good part of the morning yesterday, so I didn’t really get to see who well it worked. The system did run for a couple of hours in the afternoon, and the solar storage tank got to about 80 degrees (up from 45 degree cold inlet temperature). Today it is supposed to be sunny out, so I will have to check the tank temperature when I get home.

Popularity: 4% [?]

Solar Hot water system at work

Here is a better representation of the solar hot water system at work. Today it is 50 degrees F (10 C) and sunny outside. The return water from the solar collectors on the roof is 160 F (71 C). Picture shows about 152 F, must have been a cloud going by.

return water temperature SDHW system

The solar tank is warming up! It is about 110 degrees F at the output. Now that is more like it.

Popularity: 2% [?]

Solar Hot Water system is on line!

Boy this one took a long time. Not so much actual time to work on the project, rather, being able to work on the project, rainy weekends, summer vacations, taking delivery of the solar panels, et cetera. However, today at almost 12 noon, I flipped the switch, the little red light came on and I was greeted by the sound of rushing water. Since it is mostly cloudy out today, I wasn’t sure if there would be enough heat in the collectors to turn on, but apparently there is. When the system is running it sounds a little bit like a coffee pot percolating.

So I watched as the return water came back down the loop and the thermometer rose up to 80 degrees F. That is not too shabby considering the incoming water is 47 degrees F. That gives me a 32 degree temperature rise over 80 gallons of water, which is about 21,350 BTU. A BTU is the amount of heat required to raise the temperature of one pound of water by one degree F. Water weights 8.34 pounds per gallon, 80 gallons X 8.34 pounds equals 667 pounds. 667 pounds times 32 degrees is about 21,350 BTU.

Since the solar tank is only 80 degrees F today, which is way too cold for domestic hot water supply, it will get heated the rest of the way in the auxiliary tank.

This project was not without it’s ups and downs. Last night when I though I finished soldering all of the plumbing connections, I turned the water back on. Now, when you are soldering pipes and you go to re-pressurize the system, the last thing you want to hear is SSSSSSSSS. And yet, at 5 PM when I wife was coming down stairs to tell me she had ordered Chinese take out for diner and would I please go pick it up, I hear SSSSSSSS. After I minute, I looked down and saw a small spray of water coming from the bottom connection on the 80 gallon solar tank. The other thing about soldering, it is best done before you put water into the pipes. Any amount of water in the pipes will cool the joint enough that the solder will not stick, making all efforts to solder a good connection futile. I decided I had had enough and hooked up the hose to the drain spigot and let all the water drain out overnight.

Today, I went and got a few 1/2 inch unions, cut the tubing, removed the whole unit and soldered it again. This time, all went well. By 11:00 am the solar tank was filled. Then it was making three electrical connections for the temperature sensors and flipping the switch. I also spent a good deal of time insulating all of the pipes. I need one more piece of pipe insulation to finish the job. I filled the drainback tank up with distilled water. One of the solar contractors around here recommended putting a couple of gallons of propylene glycol which is a non-toxic antifreeze (among other things). I will pick some up tomorrow at the hardware store just to be safe.

AET AE-40 solar collectors mounted on south facing roof

Here are the AET AE-40 solar collectors mounted on the roof of the master bedroom. This is pretty much a south facing roof, the azimuth is about 192 degrees true, the collectors are tilted at 52 degrees. Man, the gutter is crooked. I will have to fix that before winter.

Sears Kenmore Miser 12 hot water tank

This is the basic system, the solar storage tank is a Sears Miser 12 80 gallon conventional electric hot water tank. The electric heating elements are not connected. Cool water is pulled off the bottom of the tank and circulated through a heat exchanger in the drainback than, then returned to the top of the tank solar tank. Basically this system acts as a water pre-heater.

solar water temperature return on a cloudy day

Even on a cool cloudy day there is enough heat gain by the collectors to turn the pumps on. The water in the bottom of the solar tank is a chilly 47 degrees F. The water coming back from the solar loop is 80 degrees F. Even though this is too cold to use as domestic hot water, this water will be heating in the auxiliary electric hot water heater to 130 degrees F for household use. Bringing the water temperature up, even a few degrees will save electric in the long run. On sunny days, I would expect the water coming back from the solar loop to be much warmer. The flow rate is a little less than 5 gallons per minute, which is a little higher than it should be for optimum collector performance. I will have to slow the pump down a little bit to get it to around 3.6 GPM.

This is a list of parts I used to build the system. I was going to include cost for each part, however, most of this equipment is made from copper, which has been spiraling upward for the last several years. Any price I list today will likely not be valid in a few months.

Manufacturer

Nomenclature

Part Number

Amount

Alternate Energy Technologies

Flat Plate Collector, glazed

AE-40

2 Each

Alternate Energy Technologies

Mounting Hardware

MH-40

2 Sets

Alternate Energy Technologies

Aluminum Strut, 1 X 1 X0.125”

6063-T52

5 Feet

RADCO industries

Drain Back Tank, 8 gallons

RDX-4004

1 Each

TACO

Circulating Pump

009F

1 Each

TACO

Circulating Pump

003B

1 Each

Watts

Tempering Valve

70A

1 Each

Rheem/Ruud

Hot Water Tank, 80 Gallon

RUE PRO80-2

1 Each

Rheem Ruud

Hot Water Tank, 40 Gallon

RUE PRO40-2

1 Each

Letro

Flow Gauge, 2-16 GPM

LDF359N

1 Each

Letro

Temperature Gauge 50-220 deg F, ¾ well

SL-2W3

3 Each

Mullen

Ball Valve, ¾ inch NPT female

R910

4 Each

Mullen

Ball Valve ¾ inch sweat

R900

2 Each

American Valve

Boiler Drain

3 Each

Gold Line

Differential Controller

GL-30

1 Each

Gold Line

10K temperature sensor

SB

2 Each

NIBCO

¾ inch union

4 Each

NIBCO

½ inch union

2 Each

CMC Howell

Type K ¾” copper tubing

60 Feet

CMC Howell

Type L 1” copper pipe

5 Feet

CMC Howell

Type L ¾” copper pipe

20 Feet

CMC Howell

Type L ½” copper pipe

10 Feet

NIBCO

1” copper cap

2 Each

NIBCO

1” copper coupling

4 Each

NIBCO

1” copper elbow, 90 degree

1 Each

NIBCO

1” copper elbow 45 degree

1 Each

NIBCO

1” to ¾” reducer

2 Each

NIBCO

¾” T

8 Each

NIBCO

¾” to ¾”NPT adaptor male

8 Each

NIBCO

¾” to ¾” NPT adaptor female

8 Each

NIBCO

¾” to ½” NPT adaptor, female

3Each

NIBCO

¾” to ½” T reducer

4 Each

NIBCO

¾” copper elbow 90

8 Each

NIBCO

½” copper elbow 90

6 Each

NIBCO

¾” copper elbow 45

6 Each

NIBCO

½” copper elbow 45

4 Each

NIBCO

¾ to ½” Reducer

2 Each

Insultube

¾” pipe insulation R5

6RX068078

72 feet

Normaco K-flex

1” pipe insulation R5

TC118C

6 feet

Normaco K-flex

½” pipe insulation R5

TC58C

12 feet

General Cable

Thermostat wire, 18 Ga, UV resistant, 210 Deg F.

5582

40 Feet

That’s it. Finally done, now I can get back to my regularly scheduled fall events like splitting fire wood and raking leaves.

Popularity: 4% [?]

Solar Hot Water installation update

Update:Todd asked for a schematic, I drew this 2D basic system diagram (click for hi-res picture):

Solar Hot Water Small

Perhaps I was a little optimistic to think that I would get all the plumbing work done in one weekend… I did make some good headway in the basement, but I am nowhere near done.

First, I build a little stand for the drainback tank to sit on. This allows the solar loop pump to be installed below the drainback tank, which I think is a good idea. I used the legs of the stand to mount the two pumps on. I would rather have the pumps attached to something rather than be supported by 3/4 inch or 1/2 inch copper pipe.

This is a double pumped system which are much more efficient at moving heat around than a single pump/convection system. Basically, there are two plumbing loops; the solar loop which runs up to the roof and through the solar collectors then back down to the drainback tank. The hot water tank loop which runs out of the bottom of the hot water tank through a heat exchanger in the bottom of the drainback tank and back into the top of the hot water tank.

The drainback tank (RADCO DBHX 6029-GC) holds eight gallons. This should be enough as each collector holds 1.6 gallons of water when operating. The total pipe run is going to be about 60 feet of 3/4 inch copper. Type K copper pipe has 0.0227 gallons per foot, so the total water in the pipe will be 1.4 gallons, which leaves a minimum of 3.4 gallons of water in the drainback tank. For a full chart of copper pipe technical data, including gallons per linear foot, check out the Copper Pipe and Tubing Cheat Sheet.  This should be enough to keep the heat exchanger submerged and keep the system operating at peak efficiency.

The solar loop uses a TACO 009F pump because of the high static head of the system. At startup, all of the water in the solar loop is in the drainback tank and has to be pumped up to the top of the solar collector, where gravity will then return it to the drainback tank. The top of the solar collector is 24 feet above the drainback tank. According to the pump spec sheet, the flow rate should be 6 gallons per minute. Taking into consideration other factors such as resistance from the pipe itself and things like elbows, temperature gauges, flow meters, etc, the flow rate will more likely be about 5 gallons per minute. Each collector is looking for 0.5 to 1.8 gallons per minute. The are plumbed in parallel, so my maximum flow rate should be no greater than 3.6 gallons per minute. I will likely have to throttle the pump down a little to attain this.

The tank side plumbing loop will use a TACO 003B circulator pump. This flow rate will be about 3 gallons per minute, just enough to keep the heat exchanger working well while not breaking the stratification of the hot water storage tank. This is a potabe water loop, so a pump with a brass casing must be used.

Drain back tank with flow gauge and thermometers for collector send and returns. Flow gauge acts as a sight glass to check drainback tank water level when system is not operating. The solar loop pump is the green unit on the lower left, the hot water tank loop pump is the brown unit on the right.

solar domestic hot water system drain back tank

Popularity: 7% [?]

Distributed Power Generation

Now that the solar collectors for my Solar Domestic Hot Water system are on the roof, and the rest of the job is simple plumbing, which I hope to have done this weekend.  I am thinking about my next project.  I don’t think we will have the money to do it this year, but next year I’d like to put in 2 kW of grid tied photovoltaics.

That is going to be expensive, I know.  I looked up the prices today of the panels and the grid tie inverter plus a tracking mount and it was a whopping $14,590.00.  The tracking mount is really not needed to make the system work, however, with a tracker you can expect a 25 percent increase in efficiency.  Federal and State tax incentives knock that down to around $10,500.00, but even so, that is about a ten year payback.

If the news is to be believed, those prices should start coming down soon because of added capacity in production of both the panels and the raw materials to make them.  Something like a 40 percent increase in manufacturing capacity last year alone.  I hope that is true for a number of reasons. I will compare prices in the spring and see if they have come down.  We do have a long list of other projects, but, perhaps I could take a second job at Lowes or the Home Depot to help pay for it.

One of the really cool things about photovoltaics, small wind turbines and micro hydro turbines is the distributed generation effect.  What this means is that instead of having a couple of huge generating plants with long high tension transmission lines bring the power to major population centers, there are many many small generators over a large area connected to the power grid and synchronized together.  This means less need for high tension power lines, huge power plants, and all the associated problems.  Demand can be met locally and more efficiently than the large power plant model.  Transmission of electrical power over any distance is inefficient, the longer the distance, the greater the inefficiency.  Its better for local small businesses (installers), better for the environment and in the long run, better for the home owner.

Popularity: 2% [?]